The meaning of life
I abhor the taking of human life; it is so wonderful, so marvellous, so unique, so miraculous. Life must have a qualitative aspect though; it must always be more than a heart beat.
Consequently I see wars as evil, along with acts of terrorism and military rebellions. I think that there are only two occasions when the taking of a human life may, just may be excusable. One of them is self defence. The other is suicide. When somebody feels that they can no longer carry the burden of living, when they feel that their life has been consistently devalued, or if they believe that there is no one with whom they can confide, they ought not to be castigated for thinking of suicide. They should, nevertheless, be given every opportunity to see that there are positive alternatives and to help them appreciate their own self value.
Our obese and hypocritical minister for Health, Harney, is hosting a conference or some media circus about suicide. This is about as sincere as holding a symposium on over-eating. The hypocrisy towards suicide shown by this and previous governments is appalling. People with potential suicidal tendencies are told by means of cinema advertising that help is available is they ask for it, but if they do they discover that because so much was spent on the cinema advertisements cutbacks have had to be made, and they have to wait maybe six months for a referral. But this government sees people with suicidal tendencies as losers. They’re not valuable like the over-paid and greedy bankers in whose interests this government formulates policies. What’s more they’re obviously not “real men” who respond to life’s problems in traditional, time-honoured fashion by having a skin-full and going home and beating the sh*($ out of the wife. So it is any wonder that the provision of adequate mental health services holds a pretty low priority.
I know of one man with suicidal tendencies who was placed on a waiting list to see a psychotherapist. Some might say he was impatient or a would-be queue-jumper. Anyway while on the waiting list he hanged himself. The HSE no doubt catalogued him as among the “DNAs” or those who Do Not Appear for their appointments, and who are, like sick people in general, the cause of our health system’s problems – at least that what Harney probably thinks. The problem isn’t just one of lack of funds. The HSE has lost quite a number of very valuable and hard-working psychotherapists, some of who have taken early retirement, citing their frustration at being bullied by HSE “littler Hitlers” who are worried that they might be squandering too many resources that are in truth only theirs to squander. managers and officials.
Even though I can’t stand Harney I wouldn’t encourage her to take her own life – though she should resign. First, she should lost a bit of weight – in fact quite a lot of weight. She’ll have to have any chance of making it through the second part of the treatment: attempting to pursue a decent lifestyle using only the pittance paid to a single person by the Department of Social Protection. I’d grant her that, even though technically her husband’s inflated income must be taken into consideration for assessment purposes, especially as he probably earns in a fortnight what most people on Social Welfare are expected to live on for a year. She would have to separate from Mr Harney (Brian isn’t it?) temporarily and live apart from him and any cash advances he might make to her would have to be assessed as “cash on hands” and therefore deducted from her benefits. The treatment should not be permanent and might last only a year: this should act as a wake-up call so that Mary Harney can taste the reality faced by many Irish people. She might very well say that she found the quality of life available perfectly adequate. The treatment would not have been a waste, as she would therefore see that she didn’t need the expensive crap like the five-star hotel suites, the first-class air travel or the en suite pianist. I would certainly class this as a result – if it’s adequate for her, it’s adequate for all her colleagues as well, plus al the senior honchos in the civil service and parastatal organisations. The savings could be considerable.





